Paper Anniversary Gifts

Celebrate one year of love and commitment with our curated paper anniversary gifts. Whether you're searching for a sentimental keepsake or a personalized memento, our collection offers a range of thoughtful and unique options to mark this special milestone. From custom photo books to elegant wall art, each item is designed to capture cherished memories and create lasting moments that will be treasured for years. Explore our paper anniversary gifts to find that perfect token of affection for your significant other.

Simple Handwritten Love Holiday Card, White, 5x7 Flat, Holiday, 100% Recycled Cardstock , Square, White

Starting at $3.88 $3.70

A white 5x7 holiday card with a scallop trim, featuring a handwritten love design on pearl shimmer cardstock.

Pros: High quality cardstock, Responsive customer service, Easy website navigation, Beautifully printed photos, Excellent customization options

Personalize Now

Little Heart Date Save The Date, Brown, 5x7 Flat, 100% Recycled Cardstock , Square, Wood

Starting at $3.64 $1.87

A stylish brown Save the Date card with a photo and nuptial details on pearl shimmer cardstock.

Pros: Fast shipping and customization options, Easy photo selection and editing, Perfect fit and size with clear clarity, Convenient magnets and address labels, High quality and attractive design

Personalize Now

Love Banner Valentine's Card, Red, Signature Smooth Cardstock, Square, Red

Starting at $3.78

A sweet Valentine's card in red with a matte finish, featuring a favorite photo and heartfelt wishes.

Pros: personalized, appearance, fun

Personalize Now

Abundant Love Valentine's Card, White, 5x7 Flat, Standard Smooth Cardstock, Square, White

Starting at $3.06

A white 5x7 Valentine's card with a matte finish, featuring elements that resemble foil or glitter.

Personalize Now

Romantic Grid Save The Date, White, 5x7 Flat, Pearl Shimmer Cardstock, Rounded, White

Starting at $3.76 $2.04

A stylish white Save the Date card with a grid design, 5x7 size, and matte finish.

Personalize Now

Upload Your Own Design Portrait Puzzle, Puzzle Board, 520 pieces, Rectangle, Puzzle, Multicolor, multi

Starting at $44.99 $33.74

A high-quality, multicolor puzzle available in various sizes and orientations, personalized with your own design.

Pros: High photo quality, Durable plastic pieces, Personalized and customizable, Fun and enjoyable, Easy to use

Personalize Now

Polka Dot Notes 5x7 Notepad, Pink, Matte, Quartz

Starting at $14.99 $10.49

A personalized pink notepad with a matte finish, perfect for jotting down notes or gifting.

Pros: Versatile and practical, Excellent customer service, Great quality, Cute and elegant design, Customizable and personalized

Personalize Now

Picture Notes Notepad, White, Matte, White

Starting at $14.99 $10.49

A personalized 5x7 notepad in white with a matte finish, perfect for jotting down notes or gifting.

Pros: Beautiful design, High quality, Great gift option, Personalization options, Sentimental value

Personalize Now

Fine Love Script Portrait Puzzle, Puzzle Board, 60 pieces, Rectangle, Puzzle, White, white

Starting at $32.99 $24.74

A personalized portrait puzzle available in multiple sizes and orientations, made of high-quality paperboard.

Pros: Good picture quality, Easy to use, Great puzzle, Sturdy and well-crafted, Unique and personalized design

Personalize Now

Rustic Wood, 8x10white

Starting at $4.99

A customizable poster print with various layouts and orientations, printed on archival-quality white paper.

Pros: Unique design, High quality, Beautiful results, Quick turnaround time, Easy to use

Personalize Now

Basic Outline Notepad, White, Matte, White

Starting at $14.99 $10.49

A personalized white notepad with a matte finish, perfect for jotting down notes or gifting.

Pros: Great gift idea, Positive feedback on design and wording, High quality and professional look, Versatile and useful, Personalization adds value

Personalize Now

Vintage Border Portrait Puzzle, Puzzle Board, 60 pieces, Rectangle, Puzzle, Beige, antique white

Starting at $32.99 $24.74

A personalized vintage puzzle available in multiple sizes and orientations, made of high-quality paperboard.

Pros: Great gift option, Unique and fun puzzle, Perfect size and fit, Quick delivery, High-quality puzzle

Personalize Now

Rustic Charm Desk Calendar, 5x11

Starting at $29.98 $26.98

A multicolor desk calendar with a durable built-in easel, printed on high-quality cardstock, measuring 5x11.

Pros: Beautiful design, Great quality, Easy to use and put together, Good size, Fast shipping

Personalize Now

Bold Memories Portrait Puzzle, Puzzle Board, 252 pieces, Rectangle, Puzzle, White, white

Starting at $34.99 $26.24

A high-quality white puzzle available in multiple sizes and orientations, personalized for a unique touch.

Pros: Easy to personalize, Great gift option, Fun and enjoyable to solve, High picture quality, Fast turnaround time

Personalize Now

Stacked Best Photos Puzzle, Puzzle Board, 1014 pieces, Rectangle, Puzzle, Green, mint

Starting at $54.99 $41.24

A personalized puzzle in various sizes and orientations, made of high-quality paperboard in green.

Pros: Beautiful design and enjoyable to solve, Personalized and unique gift option, Fast delivery and excellent customer service, Perfect for creating memories and celebrating special occasions, Great quality and well-made product

Personalize Now

A Year in Summary Art Print, Black, Signature Card Stock, 8x10white

Starting at $69.98

A high-quality art print featuring sharp images, archival quality cardstock, and customizable framing options.

Personalize Now

Majestic Milestone Anniversary Card, Gray, 5x7 Folded, Pearl Shimmer Cardstock, Square, Gray

Starting at $3.69 $3.57

A stylish, personalized gray anniversary greeting card with photos and a special message.

Pros: quality, quality product, nice design

Personalize Now

Stacked Love Art Print, Rustic, Signature Card Stock, 8x10, White, white

Starting at $69.98

A rustic Stacked Love art print on archival quality cardstock with glare-free framing options.

Pros: beautiful, good quality, sentimental value

Personalize Now

Modern Gallery of One Portrait Puzzle, Puzzle Board, 60 pieces, Rectangle, Puzzle, Multicolor, multi

Starting at $32.99 $24.74

A personalized multicolor puzzle available in various sizes and orientations, made of high-quality paperboard.

Pros: fast shipping, good gift, customizable size

Personalize Now

Circle Monogram Journal, Gray, silver lining

Starting at $25.98 $19.49

A personalized gray hardcover journal with attached bookmark ribbon and 150 lined pages.

Pros: sentimental value, usefulness as a journal, back cover design

Personalize Now

Flowered Arch Anniversary Card, Blue, 5x7 Folded, Pearl Shimmer Cardstock, Rounded, Blue

Starting at $3.97 $3.84

A personalized anniversary card in blue with flowered arch design on folded smooth cardstock.

Personalize Now

Timeless Treasure Anniversary Card, Brown, 5x7 Folded, Matte, Folded Smooth Cardstock, Rounded, Brown

Starting at $3.68 $3.67

A stylish, personalized anniversary greeting card in brown with a matte finish and square trim.

Pros: personalization, sentimental value, customization

Personalize Now

My Heart Anniversary Card, Pink, 5x7 Folded, Pearl Shimmer Cardstock, Rounded, Ballet

Starting at $3.97 $3.84

A stylish, personalized anniversary greeting card in pink with photos and a special message.

Pros: ease of use, personalization, surprise element

Personalize Now

Thriving Together Anniversary Card, White, 5x7 Folded, Matte, Folded Smooth Cardstock, Rounded, White

Starting at $3.68 $3.67

A stylish, personalized anniversary greeting card to commemorate love throughout the years.

Personalize Now

Paper Anniversary Gifts

Celebrating a first wedding anniversary is a meaningful milestone, and the tradition of giving paper gifts offers a beautiful way to honor the journey a couple has begun together. Paper symbolizes the blank page of a new marriage—fragile yet full of promise, ready to be written with shared memories and experiences. As you search for the perfect paper anniversary gift, consider how these items can become keepsakes that capture the essence of your relationship or the love story of the couple you’re celebrating. Personalized photo books, custom prints, and heartfelt cards are all thoughtful choices that allow you to showcase cherished moments, handwritten notes, or even meaningful quotes that have defined your first year together. These gifts are not only tangible reminders of your bond but also serve as a canvas for creativity and self-expression. Whether you’re selecting something for your spouse, close friends, or family members, paper gifts can be tailored to reflect individual personalities and shared experiences, making them especially meaningful.

As autumn gives way to the cozy days of November, the season naturally invites reflection and gratitude—qualities that pair perfectly with the sentiment behind paper anniversary gifts. Imagine curling up together with a photo album filled with snapshots from your first year of marriage, or gifting a set of custom stationery for love notes that will be exchanged throughout the years. For couples who appreciate the art of storytelling, consider gifts that encourage connection and creativity, such as personalized journals for documenting dreams and adventures, or wall art that transforms favorite memories into lasting decor. The versatility of paper allows you to find a gift that feels both personal and practical, whether it’s a framed print for a new home, a set of custom recipe cards for shared meals, or a calendar filled with photos from your favorite moments together. When you choose a paper anniversary gift, you’re not just giving an object—you’re offering an opportunity to reflect, reminisce, and look forward to all the pages yet to be written in your love story.

No matter who you’re shopping for, paper anniversary gifts offer an array of options that can be as unique as the couple themselves. From elegant, minimalist designs to vibrant, playful creations, there’s a style to suit every taste and relationship. These gifts are ideal for newlyweds marking their first year, but they’re also a thoughtful choice for anyone who values meaningful gestures and personalized touches. If you’re looking to make your gift even more special, consider pairing it with an experience—such as tickets to a show or a handwritten letter—to create a memory that will last long after the anniversary has passed. For more inspiration and to discover creative ways to celebrate every milestone, explore our curated collection of Unique Anniversary Gifts. Each selection is designed to help you honor the moments that matter most, ensuring your first anniversary is as memorable as the day you said “I do.”