Choosing between Shutterfly and Ravensburger for a custom photo puzzle? While both brands let you turn a favorite photo into a puzzle, the customization options are very different. From photo collages and design templates to custom text and puzzle formats, Shutterfly offers more ways to personalize the finished design.
Whether you’re creating a puzzle from a family portrait, vacation photos, or a collection of favorite memories, understanding how the two experiences compare can help you find the right fit. Here’s a closer look at how Shutterfly and Ravensburger stack up.
Shutterfly vs. Ravensburger Photo Puzzles at a Glance
| Feature | Shutterfly | Ravensburger |
|---|---|---|
| Single-photo puzzles | Yes | Yes |
| Multi-photo puzzles | Yes | No |
| Photo collage layouts | Yes | No |
| Design templates | Yes | No |
| Text on the puzzle | Yes | No |
| Occasion-specific designs | Yes | No |
| Photo upload options | Phone, computer, Facebook, Amazon Photos, and Google Photos | Computer and phone upload only |
| Save photos for future projects | Yes | No |
| Piece-count options | 60, 252, 520, and 1,014 pieces | 100 XXL, 300, 500, and 1,000 pieces |
| Large-piece puzzles | Yes | Yes |
| Puzzle box | Matching photo box | Choice of backgrounds and patterns, plus a custom puzzle name |
Photo Collages
Shutterfly
Shutterfly lets you create a puzzle from a single photo or multiple photos. You can design a collage puzzle featuring family pictures, travel memories, milestone moments, pet photos, or a mix of your favorite snapshots. Whether you’re highlighting one special event or creating a puzzle that tells a larger story, you have flexibility in how you build your design.
Ravensburger
Ravensburger custom puzzles are limited to a single photo.
Bottom Line
If you want a collage puzzle or a design that combines multiple images, Shutterfly gives you more creative freedom.
Design Templates
Shutterfly
Shutterfly offers a wide variety of design templates, including layouts created for birthdays, anniversaries, weddings, graduations, holidays, and everyday memories. You can choose a design that matches the occasion rather than having to start with a blank puzzle.
Ravensburger
Ravensburger does not offer design templates, themed designs, or layout options for custom photo puzzles.
Bottom Line
Shutterfly gives you more choices for how your finished puzzle looks.
Text Personalization
Shutterfly
With Shutterfly, you can add names, dates, captions, messages, and other custom text directly to your puzzle design. This makes it easy to personalize a gift for a birthday, anniversary, graduation, holiday, or other milestone.
Ravensburger
Ravensburger does not offer text personalization on the puzzle itself.
Bottom Line
If you want to add a personal message or customize your design with text, Shutterfly provides more options.
Photo Upload and Storage
Shutterfly
Shutterfly makes it easy to access photos from multiple sources, including your phone, computer, Facebook, Amazon Photos, and Google Photos. You can also save photos to your Shutterfly account and reuse them for future projects, making it simple to create photo books, cards, calendars, gifts, and additional puzzles later.
Ravensburger
Ravensburger allows you to upload a photo to create your puzzle. It does not offer photo storage for future projects.
Bottom Line
Shutterfly makes it easier to access, organize, and reuse your photos across future projects.
Puzzle Sizes and Piece Counts
Shutterfly
Shutterfly offers:
- 60-piece puzzles
- 252-piece puzzles
- 520-piece puzzles
- 1,014-piece puzzles
- 30-piece kids puzzles
- 50-piece large-piece puzzles
These options make it easier to find a puzzle for younger children, casual puzzlers, families, or experienced puzzle lovers.
Ravensburger
Ravensburger offers:
- 100 XXL-piece puzzles
- 300-piece puzzles
- 500-piece puzzles
- 1,000-piece puzzles
Bottom Line
Both brands offer multiple difficulty levels, but Shutterfly offers more puzzle formats and options for different ages and preferences.
Puzzle Box Customization
Shutterfly
Shutterfly puzzles arrive in a matching photo box that coordinates with your puzzle design and creates a polished presentation for gifting.
Ravensburger
Ravensburger allows customers to personalize the puzzle box with different backgrounds and patterns and add a custom puzzle name that appears on the box.
Bottom Line
Puzzle box customization is one area where Ravensburger offers an additional personalization feature.
Shutterfly vs. Ravensburger: Which Photo Puzzle Is Right for You?
Both Shutterfly and Ravensburger let you create a custom puzzle from a favorite photo, but the customization options are very different.
Ravensburger is limited to single-photo puzzles, four piece-count options, and puzzle box personalization.
Shutterfly offers more ways to customize the puzzle itself. You can create single-photo or collage puzzles, add text, choose from design templates, upload photos from multiple sources, save photos for future projects, and select from a wider range of puzzle formats.
If you’re looking for the most flexibility when creating a custom photo puzzle, Shutterfly offers more personalization options from start to finish.
Additional Resources:
