Shutterfly vs. Mpix photo ornaments: How they compare

Custom Christmas ornaments are one of the most meaningful holiday decorations because they celebrate the people, milestones, and memories that matter most. Whether you’re creating an annual family ornament, commemorating a wedding or new baby, honoring a loved one, or finding a personalized holiday gift, both Shutterfly and Mpix make it easy to turn photos into keepsakes.

While both brands offer custom photo ornaments, Shutterfly stands out with more ornament styles, more ways to personalize your design, and built-in photo editing tools that help you create something uniquely your own.

Here’s how the two compare.

Feature	Shutterfly	Mpix
Ornament Templates	700+ templates	202 Designer Photo Ornaments
Ornament Selection	Metal, glass, ceramic, wood, slate, snow globes, jeweled snowflakes, engraved designs, framed styles, and more	Metal, glass, and framed photo ornaments
Specialty Styles	Snow globes, jeweled snowflakes, engraved, framed, wood, slate, and more	Framed ornaments
Multi-Photo Layouts	Available across many templates and styles	Limited options
Custom Text	Yes	Yes
Font, Color & Background Customization	Yes	Limited
Photo Editing Tools	Crop, rotate, zoom, rotate, filters, auto-enhance	Crop, rotate, zoom
AI Photo Enhancements	Yes	No
Occasion-Specific Designs	Baby’s First Christmas, pets, memorials, family names, milestones, weddings, engagements, travel, and more	More limited selection

More Ornament Styles & Materials for Every Tree

One of the biggest differences between Shutterfly and Mpix is the variety of ornament styles available.

Both Shutterfly and Mpix offer popular options like metal, glass, and framed photo ornaments. Shutterfly expands on those choices with ornaments in unique materials like ceramic, wood, and slate, plus distinctive styles like snow globes, sparkling jeweled snowflakes, engraved designs, and more. The broader assortment means you’re not limited to traditional photo ornaments. You can choose from a wider range of materials, finishes, and styles to find something that fits your tree, décor, or gift recipient.

More Ornament Designs for the Moments That Matter

Both Shutterfly and Mpix offer professionally designed ornament templates, but Shutterfly provides significantly more options to choose from. While Mpix offers approximately 200 Designer Photo Ornaments, Shutterfly offers more than 700 ornament templates spanning a much wider variety of themes and occasions.

Rather than sorting through a smaller collection of general designs, you can start with a template created for the specific memory you’re celebrating, including:

The larger design selection means more choices from the start, making it easier to find a template you love before you begin personalizing it.

More Ways to Personalize Your Ornament

One of the biggest differences between Shutterfly and Mpix is how much flexibility you have during the design process.

With Mpix, only a few ornaments let you feature more than one photo on a single side, and the available layouts offer less room for customization.

Shutterfly gives you more control over the final design. Templates can be personalized with a single photo, multiple photos, custom text, names, dates, monograms, meaningful messages, and more. You can also change fonts, colors, backgrounds, patterns, and layouts to create something that feels uniquely personal.

Edit and Enhance Photos Without Leaving the Project

Photo editing is another area where the experience differs.

With Mpix, photo editing options are limited within the ornament design process. If you want to make significant adjustments to your image, you’ll likely need to edit it before uploading.

Shutterfly lets you make changes without leaving your project. You can zoom, crop, rotate, apply filters, and enhance photos while designing your ornament. You can also use AI-powered tools to improve images, make someone face the camera, open closed eyes, or expand a photo before printing.

Instead of working around the photo you uploaded, Shutterfly gives you more tools to perfect it before your ornament is made.

Why Choose Shutterfly for Custom Ornaments?

Both Shutterfly and Mpix help you turn favorite photos into holiday ornaments, but Shutterfly gives you more ways to personalize the final design. In addition to classic metal, glass, and framed photo ornaments, Shutterfly offers a wider variety of materials, specialty styles, templates, and customization options. With more than 700 ornament templates, multi-photo layouts, built-in photo editing tools, and unique designs for life’s biggest moments, it’s easier to create an ornament that feels personal from the start.

Whether you’re celebrating a baby’s first Christmas, honoring a loved one, showcasing a favorite pet, remembering a special trip, or continuing a family tradition, Shutterfly gives you more flexibility to create an ornament that’s uniquely yours and one you’ll look forward to displaying year after year.

Additional Resources: